Until recently I have felt some sympathy for the hapless Chancellor.
After all, he has been handed a hideous legacy by his boss and predecessor at the Treasury, Gordon Brown. Most of his previous blunders and u-turns have been attempts to sort out problems created by Brown.
But Mr Darling has this week displayed staggering incompetence in his approach to the housing market. The property sector is absolutely vital to economic confidence and yet in his bid to shore it up blundering Mr Darling has caused havoc with it, leaving it in a worse state than ever.
By floating the idea of a stamp duty holiday, but refusing to confirm it, Darling has injected massive uncertainty into an already stagnant market. Prospective buyers will now sit on their hands until the Chancellor makes clear what his stamp duty proposals are. Yet he does not propose to do so until the late autumn.
So, instead of reviving the volume of sales as was his intent, Darling has actually stifled it even further. Barely a house will be sold for the rest of the summer because stamp duty is such a massive component of the costs of moving and the prospect of avoiding it will be compelling. Buyers will pull out, deals will fall through, family plans will be left in shreds.
That is incompetence of a very high order - sufficient to shatter any last vestiges of credibility Darling had left in the kitty.
Waffling about changing the tax regime applied to the housing market without any firm proposals is perhaps the 21st century equivalent of publicly pondering devaluing the currency - a total no-no for a finance minister.
After u-turning on everything from inheritance tax and the Treasury's fiscal rules to the 10p tax rate and capital gains tax AND throwing shed loads of public money at Northern Rock, Darling was already looking hugely accident prone.
But his absurd intervention into the housing market is a bigger sin than all of these. Messing up the biggest financial asset of most British families in this way is unforgivable.
The present uncertainty is simply unsustainable. Mark my words, the Treasury will have to issue a "clarification" on stamp duty before the end of this month, never mind about October or November.
When it does Darling will cut an even more ridiculous figure than he does now. By all accounts he is a decent and honourable man. He must know he has committed a political hanging offence. He should therefore hand in his resignation immediately.
ALISTAIR DARLING
13.08.2008, 11:57am
Why only Alistair Darling? He hasn't done anything, literally. He took over the mess left by Brown and has carried on on his orders. Who is to replace him? There is not one, not one, possible candidate for the job any better that we know of. The sad fact is that the government party is totally lacking in administratative talent and we are stuck with them until the next election and, within limits, they can determine when that is to be.
Some democracy, some constitution.
Posted by: Bentrovato Report Comment
HE HAS JOINED THE "BUFFOON CLUB"
08.08.2008, 10:20am
He has joined up with the other inept bunch of chancers,this "government" is full of left wing loonies all hell bent on doing nothing apart from claiming fat expenses and cliniging on to power for its own end.Wont be long now they will all be on the dole,apart from cabinet of course ,they will be doing the round of chat shows,taking seats on boards,yes when it comes to their own well being they seem to come into their own.
Posted by: joles1234 Report Comment
TOO RIGHT, WHY ARE WE NOT IN THE EURO
07.08.2008, 7:49pm
Where is Norman Lamont when we need him?
Posted by: brusselssprouts Report Comment
POOR OLD ALISTAIR.
07.08.2008, 6:42pm
You wouldnt want to be Alistair Darling, would you?
He's like a boil on the backside of a sick old elephant.
How he wishes he could turn back the clock 5 or 6 years, and conduct the economy properly, with the runaway property market brought well under control.
He has my sympathy. Others have dropped him right in it.
Posted by: stevewo Report Comment
WHAT DID DARLING DO IN HIS PREVIOUS LIFE?
07.08.2008, 6:26pm
Seems any politician can pretend to be an expert in the post he was put into - these posts are changed on a frequent basis -
Would you put a road sweeper in charge of the Bank of England? ( no insult to road sweepers - you can see the result of their efforts)
The whole Labour gov should go - make your MP if Labour worried - contact them and tell them what you think -
Posted by: noway Report Comment
HE WILL NOT BE LONELY ?
07.08.2008, 4:34pm
Thay should all resign , if they had one ounce of honour between them ?
I would not hold my breadth though, Labour and the word Honour is not really a match made in heaven !
Posted by: HarriUK Report Comment
To view all 'Have Your Say' comments, click this button...